Fancy Pizza#1 Shrimp Scampi Pizza
Lemon & garlic, shrimp, scallions, tomato and garlic.
Small $18.50 · Large $24.504.5 ★ · 1,775 reviews Sutton’s neighborhood pizza house
Real-deal pizza,right off 146.
Hand-stretched pies, overstuffed subs on Syrian bread, big Greek salads and Italian dinners — served fast, priced right, and made the way Sutton has loved for years.
19pizzas on the menu
40+subs & sandwiches
7 daysa week from 11am
Local favorites
See the full menu What Sutton orders.
A few house favorites to get you started — the full menu has 130+ more.
Fancy Pizza
Hot SubSteak Deluxe
Steak, grilled onions, peppers & mushrooms with American.
From $14.55
SaladOriginal Greek
Feta, olives, pepperoncini, egg and warm pita.
$14.25
Everyday SpecialChicken Finger Dinner
Crispy fingers, fries and sweet & sour sauce.
$14.95
Plenty of parking.Big dining room, booths & counter seats.
Our promise
Exceptional food at a reasonable price.
At Tony’s, we pride ourselves on a consistently exceptional product at a reasonable price — and we guarantee complete satisfaction with every order.
- Made to order — pizzas hand-stretched and baked fresh, subs built the way you like them.
- Room for everyone — a big, comfortable dining room with booths for families, teams and groups.
- Satisfaction guaranteed — if something isn’t right, call us at 508-865-9544 and we’ll make it right.
The menu
Browse everything Something for every craving.
Everyday specials
All Dinners Dinner’s handled.
Complete dinners at one easy price — plus free ice cream for kids who dine in, and our fish sub every Friday.
Every day
Chicken Finger Dinner
French Fries and sweet & sour sauce.
$14.95Every day
Chicken Wing Dinner
French Fries and BBQ Sauce.
$14.95Every day
Buffalo Wing Dinner
French Fries and Blue Cheese.
$14.95Mon – Thu
Chicken & Rice
Chicken and rice, Monday through Thursday.
$16.95Every day
Chicken & Broccoli
Chicken and Broccoli in lemon & garlic.
$17.25Every day
Pasta with Mushrooms
Mushrooms and Sauce.
$13.95Reviews
Sutton’s been talking.
4.5
From 1,775 reviews on Google.Tony’s Pizza Restaurant · Sutton
“Pizza, calzones, salads and gluten-free pizzas are go-to items for our family.”Google review
“Good size menu, good service, plenty of parking, big place inside.”Google review
Photos
See all photos Straight from the oven.
Hungry yet?
Order ahead and skip the wait.
Order online for pickup, call it in, or grab a booth in our big dining room on Route 146.