House Original
The Brick$10.99
Our pepperoni roll, stuffed with peppers & provolone, pressed on the panini grill.
Since 1974 · Liberty Township, Ohio
The Valley’s Italian market, deli & bakery.
Imported groceries, meats and cheeses cut to order, scratch-made pastas, bricks and subs, and a pastry case worth the drive — all under one roof.
★★★★★ 4.7 on Google · 560+ reviews
Curbside pickup
Family owned for 50+ years
One stop, three ways
Shop it. Eat it. Celebrate with it.
Jimmy’s grew from a tiny gift shop into one of the biggest and busiest Italian deli-bakeries around. Here’s what’s waiting inside.
The Market & Deli
Imported pastas, oils and sauces, a wall of wine, and one of the largest selections of Italian meats and cheeses — sliced fresh to order.
Explore the market
Lunch & Hot Kitchen
Bricks, subs and wraps made fresh daily, homemade cavatelli, wedding soup, square pizza and our famous pepperoni rolls.
See the menu
Bakery & Custom Cakes
Cannoli, cream puffs, rum peaches and Irene’s famous brownie — plus custom cakes for birthdays, showers and weddings.
Visit the bakery
Est.1974
Our story
Read our story
It started in a garage on West Federal Street.
Jimmy & Irene opened a small Italian gift shop selling imported glassware and dishes — less than a mile from where we stand today.
Fifty years later, their passion for food and for treating every customer like family has grown into an award-winning specialty food destination. The hand-painted red, white and green signs are gone, but the recipes, the hospitality and the line out the door on Christmas Eve are still right here.
50+Years in the Valley
4.7★560+ Google reviews
DailyBread & pastry baked fresh
Customer favorites
Full menu
What everybody orders
Deli Classic
Italian Deluxe$7.99
Prosciutto, capicola, salame, provolone and hot or mild peppers.
Most Popular
Chocolate-Dipped Cannoli$3.99
Crisp shells, sweet ricotta & chocolate bits — filled fresh.
From the Ovens
Square Pizza by the Slice$1.25
Hot Farmers, Sweet Farmers, Margherita & more — baked every morning.
La Piazza
Lunch in the courtyard.
Grab a Brick and a slice, then find a seat outside. Our stone courtyard — fountain, umbrellas, string lights and all — is the closest thing to a café in Italy you’ll find on Belmont Avenue.
Plan your visit★★★★★
“You can’t beat the service, quality of food or prices.”— Google review
★★★★★
“Handmade pasta, meatballs and beautiful Italian pastries for supper tonight!”— Google review
★★★★★
“The pizza is awesome as well, and can be served by the slice or whole pie.”— Google review
Holidays at Jimmy’s
The Feast starts here.
For generations of Valley families, Christmas Eve means a trip to Jimmy’s for seafood — and running into old friends in line. Plan ahead for holiday seafood, cookie trays, antipasto platters and family-size pans.
Hungry yet?
Order ahead for curbside pickup, or call in your order and we'll have it ready.
Visit us
Get directions
Stop in — we’ll slice it fresh.
Phone(330) 759-2904
| Tuesday | 10am – 5pm |
| Wednesday | 10am – 5pm |
| Thursday | 10am – 5pm |
| Friday | 10am – 5pm |
| Saturday | 10am – 4pm |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |