Fifty years of la famiglia.
From a garage on West Federal Street to the Valley’s premier Italian experience.
“An experience like no other.”
Driven by Jimmy & Irene’s passion for food, vision of excellence and commitment to customer service, Jimmy’s has become a true Mahoning Valley institution.
What started as an Italian gift shop selling imported glassware and dishes has grown into an award-winning specialty food retailer: imported Italian groceries, homemade breads, cakes, cookies and pastries, one of the largest selections of Italian deli meats and cheeses — all cut fresh to order — gift baskets, and the best lunch in the area.
Today the family tradition carries on with a team that knows many customers by name. With something to delight even the most discriminating palate, we invite you to enjoy the results of our proud Italian heritage.
A gift shop in a garage
Jimmy & Irene open on West Federal Street in Youngstown, selling imported Italian glassware and dishes.
Groceries, deli & bakery
Imported foods, a deli counter and a from-scratch bakery turn Jimmy’s into a neighborhood favorite.
A home of our own
Jimmy’s moves into its signature yellow building on Belmont Ave — less than a mile from where it all began.
Doubling in size
A major expansion grows the grocery section, hot-food deli, bakery and dining area.
50+ years & counting
Online ordering, curbside pickup and the same recipes Valley families have loved for generations.
Everything for your Italian table.
Walk the aisles and you’ll find what your nonna would have kept in her pantry — and a few things she would have been jealous of.
Deli & Cheese
Prosciutto di Parma, soppressata, capicola, mortadella, Brier Hill sausage and imported cheeses — sliced to order.
Imported Grocery
Pastas, San Marzano tomatoes, olive oils, vinegars, coffee, cookies and specialty pantry staples.
Wine
A large selection of domestic and imported wines to pair with dinner — just ask for a recommendation.
Fresh Daily
Homemade bread, produce chosen each day from local vendors, and gift baskets made to order.
Our commitment to community.
Jimmy’s is a gathering place — whether it’s Christmas Eve in line for seafood, a Saturday lunch in the courtyard, or a cake for your family’s big day. We’re proud to be a local cultural fixture — right down to the shelf of books by local authors on Youngstown history.
Come see us.
Open Tuesday through Saturday on Belmont Avenue in Liberty Township.