WebologyWORX

Sample redesign by WebologyWORX · Concept for Pinocchio's Pizza & Subs, not the official website

About this project Get one for your business →
Open today 74 Winthrop St · Harvard Square
(617) 876-4897
Pinocchio’sPizza & Subs · Est. 1966
HomeMenuOur PizzaOur StoryCateringHours & Location Order Online (617) 876-4897
Home / Sicilian vs. Regular
The pizza

Sicilian vs. Regular.

Two very different pies, both made fresh in our Winthrop Street kitchen. Here’s everything you need to pick the right one.

Sicilian

Thick, airy, cut into squares.

Our Sicilian is a deep-dish, thick-crust pizza baked in a rectangular pan. The result is a light, spongy interior with a golden, crisp bottom — the slice Harvard Square has lined up for since 1966.

9-slice16" × 16"
Feeds3–5
From$28.50
15-slice28" × 16"
Feeds6–9
From$45.00
Sicilian cheese pizza
Regular round pizza, half pepperoni
Regular

Thin, round & Neapolitan-style.

Our regular pizza is a classic thin-crust round. It’s crisp, foldable and perfect for a smaller group or a solo late-night run.

Small12"
Feeds1–2
From$14.75
Large16"
Feeds2–4
From$20.10
Gluten free

10" gluten-free crust

A round, thin crust cooked to order with any toppings you like. Allow about 20 minutes.

Fast

Ready in 10–15 minutes

Any of our pizzas can be made in about 10 to 15 minutes — eat in our dining room or take it out.

By the slice

Slices all day

Sicilian squares are always coming out of the oven. Stop by the counter and grab one (or two).

How much to order

Pizza for every size crowd.

Group sizeSicilianRegular
1–2 peopleLate-night study break
Slices1 small
3–5 peopleRoommates & friends
1 × 9-slice2 large
6–9 peopleStudy group or team
1 × 15-slice3 large
15–20 peopleOffice lunch or club meeting
2–3 × 15-slice—
FAQ

Good questions, good answers.

What makes Sicilian pizza different?

Sicilian pizza traces back to Palermo’s sfincione — a thick, spongy, pan-baked pizza. Ours is baked in a deep rectangular pan and cut into squares, so you get a soft, airy middle and a crisp, golden bottom.

What’s the most popular slice?

Ask any regular and you’ll hear “tomato basil.” Pepperoni, buffalo chicken and BBQ chicken are close behind.

Do you have gluten-free pizza?

Yes — a 10" round thin crust, cooked to order with any toppings. It takes about 20 minutes.

Can I eat in?

Absolutely. We have a cozy dining room lined with decades of photos — see if you can spot the famous faces.

How late are you open?

Until 1 AM Monday through Saturday and midnight on Sunday. During the school year (September–May) we stay open until 2 AM on Friday and Saturday nights.

And always remember: Eat More Pizza!

Hungry? We’re open late.

Call ahead and your order is hot in 10–15 minutes — or get it delivered through DoorDash, Uber Eats or Grubhub.