Most popular
Mimi's Mud & Vanilla
Espresso ice cream with fudge, chocolate chips and chocolate cookies, layered with our pure Madagascar vanilla.
$75
Ice cream cakes & pies
The cake everyone
The cake everyone
actually wants.
Totally filled with our handmade ice cream, layered with caramel and cookie crunch, and decorated your way. Serves 10–16.
Choose your combo
Two signature cakes. $75 each.
Each cake pairs two of our most-loved flavors, separated by a thin layer of house caramel and cookie bits.
Kid favorite
Cookie Break & Galaxy
A vanilla base loaded with chocolate cookies and graham crackers, paired with our stracciatella-style chocolate chip.
$75
How it works
Four easy steps to cake day.
Pick your combo
Mimi's Mud & Vanilla or Cookie Break & Galaxy.
Make it yours
Choose frosting colors, toppings and a custom message.
Give us 3 days
Every cake is built to order — 3 days' notice required.
Pick up & party
Grab it at the shop and get it into a freezer within the hour.
Need it sooner? Ask about our ice cream pies or any display cakes we have ready to go in the freezer.
Request a cake
Tell us about your celebration.
Send your request and we'll call to confirm details and payment. Prefer to talk it through? Ring the shop any day from 11am.
- Serves 10–16 people
- Custom frosting colors, toppings & writing
- Plain “hockey puck” style available — no frosting, all ice cream
Good to know
Questions & accessibility
Why is ice cream priced by weight?
So you can have exactly what you want. Mix as many flavors as you like in any size cup or cone — you only pay for what's in it.
Do you have gluten-free and dairy-free options?
Yes! Most of our flavors are gluten-free, and we always have vegan ice creams and dairy-free sorbets in the case. We also offer a gluten-free & vegan waffle cone. Dairy-free selections are served in cups or house-made waffle cones.
Can I taste before I order?
Absolutely. Ask for a sample spoon of anything in the case.
How long does an ice cream cake keep?
Get it into the freezer within an hour of pickup. Let it sit out for 10–15 minutes before slicing with a warm knife.
Can I buy a pint to take home?
Yes — hand-packed pints are $15. Check the pint list or call ahead to make sure your favorite is in stock.
Is the shop accessible?
Our full flavor list is always available on this website in screen-reader-friendly text, and our team is happy to read the board, describe flavors or help with an order. Call us at (707) 823-5902 or email info@screaminmimisicecream.com if you need assistance.