Best sellerTotonno's Traditional
$25Hand-made mozzarella, Italian tomato, grated cheese and a drizzle of olive oil on a thin, blistered coal-oven crust.
Anthony "Totonno" Pero learned the craft at Lombardi's, then opened his own pizzeria here in 1924. His family still makes every pie the same way: dough mixed fresh daily, hand-made mozzarella, Italian tomatoes, and the heat of a coal-fired oven.



Totonno's has never chased trends. The menu is short on purpose. Pick the classic red or the white, then add a topping or two if you like.
Best sellerHand-made mozzarella, Italian tomato, grated cheese and a drizzle of olive oil on a thin, blistered coal-oven crust.
Critics' pickNo sauce, all character: mozzarella, grated cheese and olive oil. Time Out New York has called it the best thing on the menu.


Anthony "Totonno" Pero arrived from Naples and started making pizza at Lombardi's in Little Italy in 1903. In 1924 he brought that know-how to Coney Island and opened Totonno's on Neptune Avenue.
A century later his grandchildren run the shop. It has come back from two fires and Hurricane Sandy, and the recipe has never changed.
It's an old-school pizzeria with old-school rules. Here's what regulars know.
Totonno's is open Saturday and Sunday from noon to 5:30 PM. Early afternoon is the sweet spot.
No slices here. Each pie is made to order and comes out of the coal oven in minutes.
Paying in person? Cash keeps the line moving. Ordering through an app works too.
Seating is closed for now, so take your pie a few blocks to the Coney Island boardwalk.
Simply the best pizzeria in the world.Robert SietsemaEater New York
Only God makes better pizza.Zagatas quoted by the Staten Island Advance
Voted the #1 pizza in America.Food NetworkNational pizza ranking
"One of the oldest and best pizzerias in BK. Nice thin crust and fresh ingredients."
Andrew T. · Uber Eats"This is my favorite pizza place in NYC and has been so for over 25 years."
J. S. · Google"It was delicious! Perfect pizza!"
Diane S. · Uber EatsOrder a whole pie for pickup or delivery through your favorite app, or call the shop during weekend hours. Pies are made to order in the coal oven, so a short wait is part of the tradition.