Home / Press & Awards
In the newsPress & Awards
A century of headlines, from the James Beard Foundation to Netflix. Here's what the world has said about Totonno's.
Honors
Awards & recognition
2009
James Beard Foundation Award
Named one of "America's Classics," honoring regional restaurants with timeless appeal.
Food Network
#1 Pizza in America
Voted the top pizza in the country in Food Network's ranking.
2010 & 2013
Borough President Proclamations
Brooklyn honored Totonno's with official proclamations, including one for its 2013 grand reopening.
Zagat
"Only God makes better pizza."
Zagat's famous verdict, as quoted by the Staten Island Advance.
On screen
Seen on TV & streaming

Somebody Feed Phil
Phil Rosenthal stopped by Totonno's on his Netflix food-and-travel series.

Food Network
Voted #1 Pizza in America. The sign hangs proudly over the counter.
Read all about it
Featured stories

The New York Times
Sandy-Ravaged Totonno's to Get a Helping Hand
Pete Wells · Diner's Journal →
NPR
After Sandy, Pilgrimages to 'Church of N.Y. Pizza' On Hold
Joel Rose →
Serious Eats
Restoring Our Church of Pizza: Rebuilding Totonno's After Hurricane Sandy
Chris E. Crowley →
PRI's The World
The Spiritual Home of New York Pizza Struggles to Re-Open After Sandy
Marco Werman →
NY Daily News
Famous Coney Island pizza shop Totonno's reopens after Hurricane Sandy
Mark Morales →
TODAY
Survey: The country's favorite pizza topping is...
TODAY Food →
Staten Island Advance

Coney Island · Since 1924








