WebologyWORX

Sample redesign by WebologyWORX · Concept for Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana, not the official website

About this project Get one for your business →
Open Sat & Sun · Noon–5:30 PM · Takeout & delivery only
Totonno'sConey Island · Since 1924
Coney Island, Brooklyn · Est. 1924

A century of coal-oven pizza on Neptune Avenue.

Anthony "Totonno" Pero learned the craft at Lombardi's, then opened his own pizzeria here in 1924. His family still makes every pie the same way: dough mixed fresh daily, hand-made mozzarella, Italian tomatoes, and the heat of a coal-fired oven.

1924Same address
100+Years, one family
CoalFired brick oven
#1Pizza in
America
Food Network
A whole Totonno's pie fresh from the coal oven
Fresh from the coal oven
Totonno's storefront on Neptune Avenue
1524 Neptune Ave
Anthony Totonno Pero in his pizzeria
Totonno himself
Sat & SunNoon – 5:30 PM
Takeout & DeliveryNo indoor seating right now
Whole Pies Only14" pies, no slices
1524 Neptune AvenueBetween W 15th & W 16th St
James Beard Foundation · America's Classics 2009Voted #1 Pizza in America · Food NetworkFeatured on Netflix's Somebody Feed PhilThe New York TimesZagatNPRSerious EatsTime Out New YorkEater NYJames Beard Foundation · America's Classics 2009Voted #1 Pizza in America · Food NetworkFeatured on Netflix's Somebody Feed PhilThe New York TimesZagatNPRSerious EatsTime Out New YorkEater NY
The Pies

Two pies. Perfected over 100 years.

Totonno's has never chased trends. The menu is short on purpose. Pick the classic red or the white, then add a topping or two if you like.

Totonno's traditional pizzaBest seller

Totonno's Traditional

$25

Hand-made mozzarella, Italian tomato, grated cheese and a drizzle of olive oil on a thin, blistered coal-oven crust.

14" whole pieCoal-firedAdd toppings
Totonno's white pizzaCritics' pick

Totonno's White

$25

No sauce, all character: mozzarella, grated cheese and olive oil. Time Out New York has called it the best thing on the menu.

14" whole pieCoal-firedNo tomato
Pulling a pie from the coal ovenLombardi's, 1905
From Lombardi's, 1905 →
Our Story

America's oldest family-run pizzeria.

Anthony "Totonno" Pero arrived from Naples and started making pizza at Lombardi's in Little Italy in 1903. In 1924 he brought that know-how to Coney Island and opened Totonno's on Neptune Avenue.

A century later his grandchildren run the shop. It has come back from two fires and Hurricane Sandy, and the recipe has never changed.

  • Pies made in the same location since 1924
  • James Beard Foundation "America's Classics" honoree
  • Recognized by two Brooklyn Borough President proclamations
Read the full story
1924Opened on Neptune Avenue, and never moved
3rdGeneration of the Pero family behind the counter
2009James Beard "America's Classics" award
2013Reopened after Hurricane Sandy, stronger than ever
First visit?

How to do Totonno's right.

It's an old-school pizzeria with old-school rules. Here's what regulars know.

Come on the weekend

Totonno's is open Saturday and Sunday from noon to 5:30 PM. Early afternoon is the sweet spot.

Order the whole pie

No slices here. Each pie is made to order and comes out of the coal oven in minutes.

Bring cash

Paying in person? Cash keeps the line moving. Ordering through an app works too.

Eat by the ocean

Seating is closed for now, so take your pie a few blocks to the Coney Island boardwalk.

What people say

Praised by critics. Loved by Brooklyn.

Simply the best pizzeria in the world.
Robert SietsemaEater New York
Only God makes better pizza.
Zagatas quoted by the Staten Island Advance
Voted the #1 pizza in America.
Food NetworkNational pizza ranking
★★★★★

"One of the oldest and best pizzerias in BK. Nice thin crust and fresh ingredients."

Andrew T. · Uber Eats
★★★★★

"This is my favorite pizza place in NYC and has been so for over 25 years."

J. S. · Google
★★★★★

"It was delicious! Perfect pizza!"

Diane S. · Uber Eats
Inside the shop

100 years on the walls.

Open the gallery
Totonno's dining room Pie with peppers Cookie making a pie Totonno's awning Counter with Food Network sign James Beard award White pie Customers outside Sausage pie Totonno's t-shirt Photo wall
Order ahead

Skip the line. Get the pie.

Order a whole pie for pickup or delivery through your favorite app, or call the shop during weekend hours. Pies are made to order in the coal oven, so a short wait is part of the tradition.

Find us

Neptune Ave, Coney Island

  • SaturdayNoon – 5:30 PM
  • SundayNoon – 5:30 PM
  • Monday – FridayClosed
Takeout & delivery only. There's no indoor seating right now, and pies are sold whole. Grab yours and walk a few blocks to the boardwalk.
CallOrderDirections