Plan your visit
Open weekends for takeout and delivery. Here's everything you need before you make the trip to Coney Island.
Neptune Ave, Coney Island
- SaturdayNoon – 5:30 PM
- SundayNoon – 5:30 PM
- Monday – FridayClosed
Frequently asked questions
When is Totonno's open?
Saturday and Sunday from noon to 5:30 PM. The shop is closed Monday through Friday.
Can I eat inside?
Not right now. Totonno's is takeout and delivery only, with no indoor seating. Plenty of regulars carry their pie a few blocks to the Coney Island boardwalk.
Do you sell pizza by the slice?
No. Totonno's has always sold whole pies only. Every pie is 14 inches and baked to order.
How do I pay?
Bring cash if you're paying at the shop. You can also order and pay ahead through Slice, Grubhub, DoorDash or Uber Eats.
Can I order ahead?
Yes. Order online through one of our delivery partners, or call (718) 372-8606 during weekend hours.
How do I get there by subway?
Take the D, F, N or Q to Coney Island–Stillwell Avenue. From there it's about a 10-minute walk west to Neptune Avenue between West 15th and West 16th Streets.
Is the oven really coal-fired?
Yes. Totonno's bakes in a coal-fired brick oven, one of only a handful still operating in New York City. It's what gives the crust its char and crunch.
Skip the line. Get the pie.
Order a whole pie for pickup or delivery through your favorite app, or call the shop during weekend hours. Pies are made to order in the coal oven, so a short wait is part of the tradition.
Business & media inquiries
For press, partnership or business investment and purchase inquiries, please contact the family directly.

Coney Island · Since 1924