Home / Menu
Coal-oven pizzaThe Menu
Short, simple, and unchanged for generations. Every pie is a 14-inch whole pie, made to order and baked in the coal oven.
Order ahead
Skip the line. Get the pie.
Order a whole pie for pickup or delivery through your favorite app, or call the shop during weekend hours. Pies are made to order in the coal oven, so a short wait is part of the tradition.
What goes into every pie
Four things we never cut corners on.
Fresh dough, daily
Mixed every morning and never refrigerated, the way Totonno did it.
Hand-made mozzarella
Soft, milky mozzarella that melts into the sauce rather than sitting on top.
Imported from Italy
Italian tomatoes and ingredients that give the pie its bright, clean flavor.
A coal-fired oven
Intense heat for a thin, crisp, leopard-spotted crust you can't fake.

Coney Island · Since 1924