WebologyWORX

Sample redesign by WebologyWORX · Concept for Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana, not the official website

About this project Get one for your business →
Open Sat & Sun · Noon–5:30 PM · Takeout & delivery only
Totonno'sConey Island · Since 1924
Home / Our Story
Since 1924

One family. One oven.
One hundred years.

Totonno's is a pizzeria, a Coney Island landmark and a family heirloom. This is how it got here.

Anthony Totonno PeroFamily portraits
Anthony "Totonno" Pero
The founder

It started with a man called Totonno.

"Totonno" is the Neapolitan nickname for Antonio, and Anthony Pero brought both the name and the craft from Naples. He learned to make pizza at Lombardi's, then in 1924 opened a place of his own by the sea in Coney Island.

The shop has stayed in the family for three generations. Its owners call it the oldest continuously operating, family-owned pizzeria in America, and the walls are lined with a century of photos, clippings and awards.

See the photo archive
Timeline

A century on Neptune Avenue

1903
Naples to Little Italy

Naples to Little Italy

Anthony "Totonno" Pero, newly arrived from Naples, starts making pizza at Lombardi's on Spring Street, widely called America's first licensed pizzeria.

1924
Totonno's opens

Totonno's opens

Totonno strikes out on his own and opens a pizzeria at 1524 Neptune Avenue in Coney Island. Pies have been made at this address ever since.

1950s
Jerry takes the peel

Jerry takes the peel

When Totonno falls ill, his son Jerry Pero begins making the pies. He stays the shop's main pizza maker into the 1990s.

1994
Cookie steps up

Cookie steps up

After Jerry's death, his daughter Louise "Cookie" Ciminieri takes over and keeps the family recipe and the family rules intact.

2009
Fire, then a James Beard award

Fire, then a James Beard award

A major fire closes the shop for 11 months. The same year, the James Beard Foundation names Totonno's one of America's Classics.

2012
Hurricane Sandy

Hurricane Sandy

Sandy floods Coney Island and closes Totonno's for five months. Friends and fans rally, including Geja's Café in Chicago, whose fundraising buys a new dough machine.

2013
Back in business

Back in business

Totonno's reopens to lines down Neptune Avenue, and the Brooklyn Borough President marks the occasion with an official proclamation.

Today
The third generation

The third generation

Totonno's grandchildren still run the shop, serving whole pies for takeout and delivery every weekend, just as good as they've ever been.

The craft

Nothing about the pie has changed.

The family works with imported Italian ingredients, hand-made mozzarella and dough made fresh every day. It's never refrigerated.

Daily dough

Made each morning and left to rise naturally.

Fresh mozzarella

Made by hand for a soft, creamy melt.

Italian imports

Tomatoes and ingredients sourced from Italy.

Coal-fired heat

One of the few coal ovens left in New York City.

The family

The people behind the pies.

Jerry Pero
Second generation

Jerry Pero

Totonno's son, and the shop's main pizza maker from the 1950s into the 1990s.

Louise Cookie Ciminieri
Third generation

Louise "Cookie" Ciminieri

Jerry's daughter, who took over in 1994 and became a Coney Island legend in her own right.

The family in 2013
Third generation

Antoinette & Frank Balzano

Cookie's siblings and co-owners, keeping the doors open and the oven hot every weekend.

CallOrderDirections